Dr. Suzanne Simpson

How to Support a Student Who Is Struggling in Class

QUICK ANSWER

Support is the word educators most commonly use to describe their relationship with struggling students. It is also the word most likely to mean something different to the educator than to the student. In this conversation with a pastor who has spent decades offering support to people in poverty, crisis, and pain, we explore what genuine support requires, why it starts with being seen, and what prevents most people from offering it even when they genuinely want to.
Are you a parent? Read the home version here.
This post is part of the Get on Their Turf series. Start with the foundation post here:
Getting on Their Turf: The Complete Educator Guide to Connection, Trust and Behaviour in the Classroom

Dave Sattler is a pastor on the North Shore who has spent the better part of two decades walking alongside people that most institutions have given up on. He works on community housing for people facing significant barriers. He runs a weekly gathering called Coffee Time for anyone in the neighbourhood who needs food and company. His phone contact list includes people who call him because almost no one else picks up.

He is not an educator. But what he has learned about support in that work is more practically useful for classroom teachers than almost anything I have heard in a professional development context. Because he has spent years giving support to people who have very little of it, in circumstances where the wrong approach does lasting damage, and he has had to figure out precisely what it requires.

My doctoral research at Simon Fraser University asked 25 teenagers in a youth psychiatric unit what they needed most from the educators in their lives. Support was named consistently – in student language, in the words they chose to describe the adults who had helped them. What those students described as support, and what Dave describes from the other side of the equation, is the same thing. And it is not what most educators think it is.

Support Is Walking Alongside, Not Getting Ahead

Dave’s working definition of support is straightforward: it is the human side of walking along the long journey with people. Not solving. Not fixing. Not managing from ahead or behind. Alongside. For however long it takes.

In a classroom, this distinction matters enormously. An educator who is trying to solve a student’s problem is positioned differently from one who is present with the student while the student works through it. The first is doing something to the student. The second is doing something with them. Students experience those two approaches completely differently – and the one that produces felt support is the second one.

In my research, when participants described feeling supported by an educator, they used the most ordinary language. “[The principal] tried his hardest to make me feel comfortable. He would make sure I was okay. He was there for me.” “[The teacher] was just there for me.” The absence of anything complicated is the point. The students were not describing elaborate interventions. They were describing presence.

One student – and this is one of the most important data points in my research – said: “Someone can’t learn if they aren’t mentally okay. And they don’t feel supported if they don’t feel that you are putting in some sort of effort to care for their mental wellbeing.” That student understood something that educational systems consistently miss: the academic and the relational are not separate tracks. You cannot have one without the other.

Seen, Known, Cared For: The Three Movements of Support

Dave described support as moving through three stages. This progression is one of the most useful frameworks I have come across for thinking about what building support with a student actually requires in practice.

First: seen. Support starts before any conversation. It starts with a student experiencing that their presence has been noticed. Not assessed, not evaluated, not categorized. Noticed. In Dave’s community work, this is the first thing he builds: spaces where people are greeted by name, where their arrival is acknowledged, where they know they have been seen.

In a classroom, being seen looks like: using a student’s name. Noticing when they are absent and saying something when they return – not about the absence, but about them. Paying enough attention to the ordinary texture of a student’s day that a shift in their energy or mood is visible to you. These are seconds, not minutes. But for a student who has spent time feeling invisible in educational settings – and my research found that many have – those seconds are significant.

Second: known. This takes longer and it cannot be rushed. Dave says it can take years, in his context, for someone who has been seen consistently to begin sharing their story. Being known means the relationship has developed enough safety that a person can bring something true to it rather than the managed version they normally present.

In a classroom, most of what you are doing when you invest in small moments of genuine contact is building toward this. The student who eventually tells you what is actually going on at home, or admits they do not understand something they have been pretending to follow, or comes to you after class about something that has nothing to do with your subject – that student is bringing you the known stage. You got there through the seen stage, repeatedly, over time. There is no shortcut.

Third: cared for. This is where Lawrence comes in – a man Dave knows who has been homeless for seven years, who was stretched out across the entire front pew during a Sunday service, suitcase beside him, possibly asleep during the sermon, completely at home. Not managed. Not processed. Belonging.

That is the felt experience of being cared for: not that someone is performing a support role toward you, but that you belong in the space you are in. For a student in your classroom, the cared-for stage looks like genuinely mattering to you as a person rather than as a learner to be managed. It is the thing that is hardest to manufacture and most immediately felt when it is real.

Support isn’t fixing
It’s walking alongside a student, not solving the problem so that you can move on.

You Never Assume

One of the most important principles Dave articulated – and one that directly mirrors what I learned at the psychiatric unit – is this: you never assume. You cannot know what is happening in a student’s life from what is visible in your classroom. And the research on this is stark.

Dr. Gordon Flett, professor of psychology at York University and the leading researcher on mattering in children and adolescents, has found through his research that approximately 35 per cent of young people feel they do not matter – while only 8 per cent of parents believe their child could feel that way. The same perceptual gap exists in schools. Educators consistently overestimate how supported their students feel. The students who are least likely to signal their struggle are often the ones carrying the most.

Dave uses the phrase “being aware of your unawareness.” The moment you accept that you genuinely do not know what is behind the surface of the student in front of you, something changes in how you approach them. The assumptions that get in the way of seeing them clearly – the mental category you have assigned them, the pattern you think you recognize – lose their grip. And you become capable of actually seeing.

My research found that teachers were identified as the single largest source of negative school experiences for struggling students. Not because those teachers were malicious. Because they were operating on assumptions rather than curiosity. They thought they knew what was going on. They did not ask.

Fighting Through the Fear

Dave named something that I have seen prevent support in educational settings more than almost anything else: fear. The fear of getting it wrong. Of overstepping. Of approaching a student in a way that is misread or unwelcome.

I shared a situation my husband had faced: a young woman, visibly intoxicated, staggering off a bus. What do you do? The answer for many people, trained by a culture that has made certain kinds of reaching out feel professionally or socially risky, is nothing. You talk yourself out of it. You walk past.

Dave’s response to this is consistent: fight through the fear. Ask the baseline question. “Are you okay? Is there anything I can do to help?” Non-confrontational. Non-demanding. An invitation that leaves the person free to respond however they need to. In his experience, the regrets are always the moments he did not reach out – never the ones he did.

In a classroom, this fear shows up as the hesitation before checking in with the student who seems withdrawn. The question you want to ask but do not because you are not sure how it will land. The decision to address a behaviour rather than ask what is underneath it because asking feels like it crosses a professional line.

The baseline question works in a classroom too. “I noticed you seem like you are carrying something today. I just wanted to check in.” Non-confrontational. Leaves the student free to respond or not. And in the data from my research, the students who reported the most significant positive experiences at school named educators who did exactly this: who noticed, who asked, who followed up. One student described a youth care worker who sent her texts when she was not coming to school: “Hey, how are you doing? I haven’t seen you in a while.” That student described that person as one of her first friends at school. One text. That is the baseline question.

Start with being seen
Notice your students before they need to talk, and the door stays open.

The Conversation Beneath the Conversation

Dave introduced a phrase in this conversation that I think belongs in every educator’s professional vocabulary: the conversation beneath the conversation.

He works in a community with significant cultural and language diversity. Often the interaction you are having on the surface is not the interaction that actually matters. Someone is telling you one thing while communicating something quite different. And getting to what is actually there requires patience – the willingness to stay in the exchange long enough for the real thing to surface, rather than resolving the surface version and moving on.

In a classroom this looks like: a student who says they are fine when they are not. A student whose presenting behaviour is disruptive but whose actual issue is something that has nothing to do with your class. A student who asks a technical question about an assignment but is actually checking whether you are someone safe to come to.

The educator who can hold enough space for the conversation beneath the conversation – who is not rushing to the next thing, who can be patient with the surface version long enough to see what is underneath – is the educator who eventually gets the real version. That patience is not passive. It is the active practice of staying present when the easy move is to resolve and move on.

What Support Gives Back

Something important came up in this conversation for educators who feel genuinely depleted – who want to offer more support to their students but do not have much left.

Dave described a paradox he has experienced across decades of this work: that giving genuine support tends to build rather than deplete your capacity. When his attention moves off his own needs and toward someone else’s, something shifts. His own difficulties look different. There is meaning in the connection that feeds him.

I found the same thing at the psychiatric unit. The first months were hard – I would leave gutted by what I had heard. But as I found my footing, those human connections became the source of my meaning in the work. I stayed for nearly six years not because the work was easy. Because of what came back in those relationships.

This is not permission to override your real limits or ignore your own wellbeing. Compassion fatigue is real and Dave has experienced it. But it is worth knowing that the energy equation of giving support is not always linear. Sometimes the act of reaching toward a student in a moment when you feel you have nothing is exactly what creates the experience that restores something. You do not always know until you try.

Dave’s phrase is worth keeping: never underestimate the reciprocation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I support a student when I only see them for one period a day and have thirty others in the room?
You work at the level of the seen stage. Being seen does not require time – it requires attention. A name used genuinely. A follow-up on something a student mentioned last week. A brief, private check-in during independent work. Thirty seconds of real attention lands differently than thirty minutes of generic presence. You are not trying to build a relationship with thirty students simultaneously. You are trying to give each student enough small, genuine signals across a semester that they experience your classroom as a place where they exist as a person.
A student in my class is clearly struggling but has not disclosed anything. What is my role?
Your role is to notice, to ask the baseline question, and to refer when what you observe warrants it. You do not need a disclosure to bring professional concern to your school counsellor. “I have a student I want to flag – I have noticed this pattern and I wanted someone else to be aware” is sufficient. Document what you observe: specific behaviours, dates, contexts. That documentation is genuinely useful to anyone who works with the student next. Notice and refer. That is your lane.
What do I do when a student rejects every attempt I make to connect?
Lower the stakes and lengthen the timeline. You are not trying to have a breakthrough. You are trying to accumulate enough low-pressure, non-demanding contact that the student’s defences do not have to work as hard. Dave works with people who have been let down by every institution and person in their lives – and he starts by learning their name. That is the first movement of seen. It is enough to start.
I try to support students but I am running on empty. Is it ethical to offer support when I have so little to give?
Yes – and Dave’s point about reciprocation is worth sitting with here. There is a difference between having nothing and being depleted. Depleted means you need to restore. Nothing means you cannot function. If you are depleted but still functioning, the small act of genuine presence with a student who needs it may actually do more to restore your sense of purpose than any break would. That is not a reason to ignore real burnout, which requires real attention. It is a reason not to assume the equation is one-directional.
How do I know if the support I am offering is actually landing?
Watch for the second movement: being known. A student who starts bringing you things – questions that are not about the curriculum, personal observations, problems that have nothing to do with your class – is experiencing the relationship as a place where being known is possible. That is the signal. You got to seen. They are moving toward known. Keep doing what you are doing.

Listen to the Get on Their Turf Podcast

The Get on Their Turf podcast goes deeper on every topic in this guide.

About Dr. Suzanne Simpson

Dr. Suzanne Simpson is a doctoral researcher, educator, and host of the Get on Their Turf podcast. She has over 30 years of experience working with young people in educational settings, including nearly six years teaching inside a youth psychiatric unit. For her doctoral research at Simon Fraser University, she sat with 25 teenagers in psychiatric care and asked what they needed most. Their answer was clear: support, understanding, and care. Those three things are the foundation of everything she teaches. Suzanne helps parents understand teen behaviour, get on their turf, and rebuild connection at home – even when it feels hardest. She works with parents, schools, and communities across Canada.

Download the free guide 8 Ways to Get On Your Kids’ Turf at drsuzannesimpson.com

Please note that the contents of this post are not a substitute for professional advice, diagnosis, or treatment. My scope of practice is as an educator, and this work is intended to provide information for educational purposes only. Testimonials of lived experiences are opinion only and have not been scientifically evaluated.

Scroll to Top